worked well in practice. They have had no adverse
effect upon the military mission of the armed
forces or the morale and discipline of its members.
PUNISHMENTS IMPOSED
When we hear the term Status of Forces
Agreements, many of us think of the trial of our
military personnel by foreign courts for crimes
committed overseas. That association of thought
is natural. Criminal jurisdiction is one of the most
important aspects of the Status of Forces
Agreements, and certainly the one that has always
received the most publicity. Each publicized report
of an American service member being tried for
a serious crime by a foreign court brings public
outcry from Americans. Most Americans believe
the offender should be tried by United States
military authorities.
Comparisons have shown that normally a
sentence imposed by a foreign court has been
extremely lenient. There have been no instances
of cruel or unusual punishment. If you consider
the large number of United States personnel
stationed overseas and the small number of
persons confined in foreign jails at any one time,
you can see that the number confined is minimal.
In all but the most serious offenses, confinement
is suspended and the offender is returned to the
United States for reassignment or discharge.
CONFINEMENT AND CUSTODY
Equally lenient has been the attitude of the
foreign governments with regard to confinement
and custody. Most SOFAs provide that the United
States military authorities may retain custody of
an accused military member until all judicial
proceedings, including the appeal, have been
completed. If a person is eventually sentenced to
confinement in a foreign prison, American
authorities are permitted frequent visits to ensure
the person is being well treated. In addition, the
person is allowed to receive health-benefitting
items, items of comfort, and food items
considered a necessary part of an Americans diet.
RIGHTS OF SERVICE MEMBERS
The Department of Defense protects to the
maximum extent possible the rights of American
personnel who may be subject to trial by foreign
courts and imprisonment in foreign prisons. One
of the most significant safeguards afforded a
military member is the right of the United States
to have an official observer (legal representative)
at the trial. (The legal representatives duty is to
determine whether the accused military member
received all the rights guaranteed by the Status
of Forces Agreement.) The legal representative
also determines if the member received all other
rights of due process of law that the person would
have had if tried in a U.S. state court.
A military member tried in a foreign court has
one significant advantage over fellow military
members facing trial in the United States.
Congress has passed legislation that allows the
armed services to pay attorney fees and court costs
as well as to provide bail in appropriate cases. The
Department of Defense has liberally followed that
statute, and large numbers of military members
have taken advantage of its provisions.
When you are in a foreign port, remember you
are a guest in that country and are subject to
that countrys laws and legal procedures. Also
remember that whatever privileges service
members possess, as compared with ordinary
visitors or tourists in that country, they possess
them only by special consent oft he host country.
Because of the host countrys special consent, you
are allowed to drive in that country based on your
U.S. drivers license. You do not have to pay
customs duty or taxes when bringing household
goods and personal belongings, including your
car, into the host country. You are allowed to
enter and leave the country on military orders
alone without a passport or visa.
Remember that as a guest in a foreign country,
you are subject to that countrys criminal laws and
procedures. If you violate those laws, you may
find yourself on trial before a foreign court.
Only by the consent of the host country can you
be tried by the courts of your own service for
offenses committed on foreign soil. That is
permitted only because of the Status of Forces
Agreements, not as a matter of absolute right.
SUMMARY
The preliminary inquiry is an important part
of the premast procedure. You are an impartial
investigator and should seek to find all the
relevant facts of the case. Your job is to provide
the commanding officer with all the information
so that he or she can make a decision concerning
the accused.
United States Navy Regulations, 1990
describes the procedures, authority, and com-
mand of offices within the Department of the
2-21